This article presents the results of a study titled “Interculturality and the Meanings of Justice, Peace and Governability in the Post-Agreement Era in Caribbean Colombia.” The study was performed in the Sierra Nevada de Santa Marta with a focus on three indigenous communities located on the northern slopes of the mountain range: the Kaggaba, Iku and Wiwa. The epistemic construct developed in the study adopts as its starting point the meanings that the communities of the Sierra Nevada assign to their world. From this perspective, the studied populations also contribute to the meanings of the topics we address: justice, peace and governability in the post-conflict era in Colombia. In addition, the study proposes a new methodological approach based on a non-colonialist focus we term “doubly reflexive dialogic visits.” Venn diagrams are proposed as a tool to analyze the information gathered. The communities addressed—the Kaggaba, Iku and Wiwa—agree that their territories have been the setting in which part of the Colombian armed conflict has unfolded and that in certain ways the warring parties respected the ancestral customs and traditions of their communities.