Abstract Colour has been hypothesized to play a crucial role in prey capture for sit-and-wait predators that rely on visual cues to deceive their prey. Prey capture success has been directly linked to colouration in spiders; however, evidence so far focuses mostly on dorsal colouration, excluding ventral patterns that are visible to prey and may be relevant for prey attraction. Here, we explored whether the dorsal and ventral colouration of a colour polymorphic spider is associated with light environment and prey capture success. We quantified the number of prey captured across three dorsal (black, white, and yellow) and two ventral (black and a mosaic yellow/orange pattern) morphs of Gasteracantha cancriformis , considering light intensity on dorsal and ventral sides. We found that spiders capture more prey in low light environments, and that individuals often expose their dorsal colouration towards low light levels. We did not find significant differences in prey capture rate between morphs dorsally or ventrally. These results indicate that how and where spiders position their web can be more important for prey capture than colouration. Alternative hypotheses such as aposematism, camouflage and thermoregulation deserve more attention in future studies that aim to understand the role of colouration in spiders and the factors causing spider colour polymorphisms.