Significance We report signatures of a new phenomenon wherein a hidden “interdimensional” order emerges from a bulk three-dimensional superconductor tuned to approach a phase transition to an insulator. Prior electrical transport measurements found that the superconductor–insulator transition of BaPb 1− x Bi x O 3 demonstrated critical scaling behavior but inexplicably required parameters consistent only with two dimensions. Here, we directly image the three-dimensional superconducting state as it approaches an insulating phase and discover that signatures of a two-dimensional granular superconducting phase spontaneously emerge at the transition. Moreover, the properties of this phase precisely match the theory of emergent electronic granularity specific to two-dimensional materials. These findings posit that a three-dimensional superconductor electronically reorganizes itself into a two-dimensional granular superconductor before ultimately transforming to an insulator.