The application of biosolids improves soil nutrient availability and crop productivity; however, their application needs to be carefully evaluated so as to avoid the risk of contamination. In this study, a 12-month field experiment using a randomized block design with factorial arrangement was conducted to evaluate the effects of biosolids on the nitrogen and phosphorus contents of a sugarcane-cultivated inceptisol. Three types of dewatered biosolids were used: anaerobically digested (B), anaerobically digested and thermally dried (BST), and anaerobically digested and lime-stabilized (BA) biosolids. The results showed that biosolid use increases soil nitrogen content by up to 37% of the total Kjeldahl nitrogen, 42% of NO3−, 13% of NO2−, and 32% of NH4+. Biosolid treatments exceeded the phosphorus requirement for sugarcane cultivation by up to 277% for B, 170% for BST, and 368% for BA. The application of biosolids sufficient to meet crop nitrogen requirements significantly increased soil phosphorus content, suggesting an overdose and low crop response to the available phosphorus. The application of biosolids yielded results similar to those of mineral fertilizers, suggesting their potential use in agriculture.