The objective of this study was to determine individual and combined inoculation effects with ectomycorrhizal fungi (EMF) (Amanita muscaria, AM; Suillus luteus, SL; and Amanita sp., AS) on seedling growth and P uptake of Pinus patula, P. oocarpa, and P. tecunumanii. Beneficial effects of ectomycorrhizal inoculation depended on the plant species × inoculum combinations. In the case of P. patula, the benefit was evident only in P uptake and this occurred only when the three fungi were concomitantly applied. In P. tecunumanii, the effects were associated not only with P uptake but also with plant growth and not only with the triple inoculation but also with the individual (AS) and dual (AM + AS) inoculations. In P. oocarpa, AS inoculation enhanced both plant growth and P uptake, while AM inoculation only improved plant growth; triple and dual inoculation (SL+AM and SL+AS) also increased plant growth but not P uptake.